At Rachel Leibold's school, an ordinary mystery reader Friday turned unforgettable when her boyfriend, Austin, showed up to read. Imagine Rachel’s surprise, a second-grade teacher in Carmel, Indiana, expecting a routine storytime. Instead, she got a life-changing moment. Austin, in cahoots with the principal, had a plan: to propose using a story he wrote as a kid. The tale, complete with a “Shiny Head Pin” on every page, ended with a surprise last page—a proposal. This sweet moment, shared with her class, was a blend of creativity and heartfelt surprise, making it a story they'll all remember.