Curated Lists/Fashion

The 13 Best Etsy Shops For Jewelry

Rings by Melissa Tyson Designs

It’s no secret that Etsy and jewelry are a match made in heaven. In fact, it’s one of the top-selling categories on the site, and for good reason: the place is a treasure trove of fine, handmade, quality, one-of-a-kind pieces. Whether you’re a bride, a groom, or just a general fashionista with a jewelry addiction, Etsy has something for you.

Etsy hosts countless shops that lean more affordable than the markup of fine jewelry stores — and plus, your money goes directly to the maker! Many shops offer customizations so you can design your dream piece alongside a talented artisan.

With Etsy, nowhere else is it so easy to find unique statement pieces whether you’re buying for yourself or as a gift. And nowhere else will you find so many shops to sift through! It can be intimidating to wade through the wide waters of the site, but lucky for you we’ve narrowed down thousands of sellers to give you 13 of our favorite Etsy shops for jewelry.

Bridal shower gifts, presents for the mother of the bride or groom, sparkling engagement rings or maybe just everyday jewelry, let Etsy be your personal jewelry concierge. Read our glowing reviews below or hop straight to the site to get shopping.

Photo by Claire Eliza & Pearl Ring by Rings by Melissa Tyson Designs

Melissa Tyson Designs

Best for: alternative diamond and gemstone engagement rings.
Price Range: $299 – $12,000

Rings by Melissa Tyson Designs

If your dream engagement or wedding ring must be a custom work of art, then we have the shop for you! It’s no secret we’ve long been obsessed with the stunning sculptural handmade creations of Melissa Tyson Designs. Not just listed in our Best Places to Buy Engagement Rings guide, Melissa has also shared with us her secrets on how to design the perfect custom engagement ring. Melissa exclusively uses conflict-free diamonds and gemstones like moissanite and morganite to make her pieces, which she describes as “forever heirlooms with a story to tell” — we couldn’t agree more.

Shop Melissa Tyson Designs


Best for: gender-neutral wedding rings.
Price Range: $138 – $1,500

All partnerships are celebrated with LOLiDE’s handmade gender-neutral wedding and engagement bands. Modern yet
timeless, their unique creations are ethically sourced using recycled materials. Mixed metals never looked so chic!


NY Fine Jewelry

Best for: wide selection of modern, classic & timeless engagement rings.
Price Range: $178 – $2,300

NY Fine Jewelry is a mecca for the bride who makes a statement wherever she goes. This shop’s wide selection of handcrafted engagement rings and wedding bands range from vintage to art deco, moissanite to moonstone, opal to emerald, and even more. These gorgeous works of art make me want to get engaged all over again!

Shop NY Fine Jewelry

Sarah Elise Jewelry

Best for: dainty solid gold jewelry.
Price Range: $58 – $2,000

Because Etsy is so much more than engagement rings and wedding bands, we had to make mention of the fine jewelry of Sarah Elise. Elevate any look with these 14k solid gold pieces made with hand-cut gemstones and ethically sourced diamonds. This women-owned shop uses three generations old techniques — we love a family affair!

Shop Sarah Elise Jewelry


Best for: inexpensive stacking rings.
Price Range: Under $150

MasteRestaM describes their rings as “minimalist, avant-garde, and dainty” and if that isn’t a bird call to jewelry aficionados everywhere, we don’t know what is! This Las Vegas-based maker has hundreds of options in 14K solid gold/gold-filled and 925 sterling silver with an unbeatable price range — all pieces fall under $150 and most under $50.

Shop MasteRestaM

LEILA jewelry shop

Best for: affordable everyday jewelry.
Price Range: Under $150

Our pick for necklaces and bracelets also double as your next gift go-to. LEILA’s wide range of necklace styles, like bars, chokers, and discs, would make for lovely bridesmaid or mother-in-law gifts. We also love the personalized dainty chain bracelets for a chic friendship bracelet. (Are those still a thing? ‘Cause we think they should be!)

Shop LEILA Jewelry Shop


Best for: hypoallergenic earrings.
Price Range: Under $50

You’ll never have to go searching for a good pair of earrings again now that you’ve discovered Toronto’s Elevado. This women-run operation uses high-quality sterling silver and all hypoallergenic materials to create thousands (yes, thousands!) of pieces. With hoops, studs, cuffs, birthstones and more, this is your one-stop shop for ear bling.

Shop Elevado

PVD Vintage Jewelry

Best for: affordable vintage jewelry.
Price Range: Under $150

That high of finding a one-of-a-kind vintage piece of jewelry is yours from the comfort of home — what a time we live in! Providence Vintage Jewelry is a three-generation-old operation with nearly a thousand unique pieces to sift through. All their items are 100% American-made with quality materials and methods from a time when Providence was the jewelry capital of the world.

Shop PVD Vintage Jewelry

GLDN x Layered and Long

Best for: personalized jewelry gifts.
Price range: $30 – $385

Personalized jewelry makes for a fabulous gift, and the lovingly handcrafted pieces of GLDN x Layered and Long are so good you might not want to give them away. Their top-quality mixed metal necklaces and bracelets make for timeless staple pieces at a modest price point — now you can justify one for you, one for mom!

Shop GLDN x Layered and Long

Pure Love Necklace

Best for: name and initial jewelry.
Price Range: $15 – $225

It’s no wonder name/initial necklaces are so popular — it’s a sweet way to keep a loved one near to your heart (literally)! New Jersey’s Pure Love Necklace makes dainty name jewelry from quality solid 925 sterling silver and solid gold with birthstone options as well.

Shop Pure Love Necklace


Best for: affordable gemstone jewelry.
Price Range: Under $30

There is a sweet simplicity to the gemstone creations of SERENITY Project, and we can’t get enough! With delicate designs perfect for everyday wear — not to mention at an unbeatable price — you’re going to want to keep this one bookmarked come gift-giving season.

Shop SERENITY Project

Starstruck Piercings

Best for: affordable body jewelry.

Price Range: Under $20

If body piercing jewelry is your thing, we think you’re going to love Starstruck Piercings from Adelaide, Australia. Their beautiful gemstone designs — all at once funky and elegant — would look fab anywhere on the body. They even have faux body jewelry for those of us who want the look without the pain.

Shop Startstruck Piercings

Bits ‘n Pieces

Best for: festival season jewelry.
Price Range: $15 – $250

Southern California-based Bits ‘n Pieces has you covered for your next beach day, music festival, or night on the town. Dainty body and belly chains are a simple, elegant way to elevate any look. Chains are available in stainless steel or 14k gold filled depending on your price point.

Shop Bits ‘n Pieces

Shopping for wedding jewelry? Etsy is just one of the fabulous places we recommend in our Best Places to Buy Engagement Rings guide.

Share this